
Text or Call? When a Service Advisor Should Pick Up the Phone

Service Lane
Jimmy Shang
A service advisor with a finished inspection and a customer to reach faces the same choice many times a day: text or call. Text and phone do different jobs, and matching the channel to the conversation is a habit a service department can teach. At car dealerships that run on Numa, the advisor makes that choice inside one conversation, texting the customer or starting a call from it.
J.D. Power’s 2024 U.S. Customer Service Index (CSI) Study reported how customers would like to get service updates. They were four times as likely to say text message (68%) as phone call (16%).
That figure covers service updates. A complicated repair finding is a separate question, and this post takes it up.
Key takeaway: Text for the routine, call for the complicated. The photos and the estimate go in writing, and the explanation of a complicated finding goes by voice.
Why Texting Wins the Routine Update
A text suits the routine messages a service department sends all day: the car is checked in, the part arrived, the car is ready for pickup. It is quick to read, easy to answer between other things, and it leaves a written record.
An earlier post covers the best ways to handle service status updates. So the rule starts here: when the message is routine, send the text. Nothing later in this post changes that.
Why a Complicated Finding Needs a Voice
Some messages are harder to read. Several findings, a safety item and a large estimate can be taken more than one way.
Daft, Lengel and Trevino’s 1987 field study of managers in MIS Quarterly found that communication media differ in how many information cues they carry. Managers preferred rich media for ambiguous messages and less rich media for clear ones, and the data suggested higher performers were more sensitive to that fit. The idea is called media richness.
Tone can be hard to convey in writing. Kruger and colleagues’ 2005 paper in the Journal of Personality and Social Psychology suggests people tend to believe they communicate over e-mail more effectively than they do.
In one experiment, 60 university students sent sarcastic and serious statements by e-mail or by voice. Senders expected about 78% to be understood either way. E-mail readers got 56% right, and listeners got about 73%.
The authors caution that accuracy over e-mail was still high in their first study. The finding is overconfidence.
The pull toward typing has an innocent cause. Kumar and Epley’s 2021 paper in the Journal of Experimental Psychology: General found voice interactions created stronger social bonds than text-based ones, with no increase in awkwardness.
According to the University of Texas at Austin’s 2020 release on the study, people chose to type because they believed a phone call would be more awkward. In one experiment, a call with an old friend took about the same amount of time as reading and responding to e-mail.
This research covered managers, university students, old friends and strangers, and the consumer survey later in this post spans industries. Applying any of it to a service lane is an inference.
The research suggests a complicated finding can be easier to follow by voice, where the customer can ask the next question right away. It also suggests why a text can feel quicker and easier in a busy lane, for anyone.
What Text or Call Looks Like at a Dealership
The choice can come up three ways in one day at a dealership.
The oil change is done, and the advisor texts that the car is ready. The customer replies between meetings with a pickup time. The text did this job well.
Later, a multi-point inspection turns up several findings and a large estimate. The advisor has a full lane, so the findings go out in one long text. The customer reads a list of repairs and a total, with nobody to ask which one matters most.
A third customer texts a quick question. The advisor answers between customers, and the customer replies after lunch. By late afternoon the repair order is still open, waiting on an answer a short call could have settled.
Everyone in these scenes picked the channel that felt quickest, with the phones ringing and the advisors in the lane. The inspection was good work, and the open question is how its findings reach the customer.
Moving updates to text gives customers what they asked for. The limit shows on the conversations with stakes, such as a large repair decision or a delay.
A 2025 Zogby Analytics survey for Five9, a contact-center software company, polled 1,006 respondents across the U.S., the U.K. and Canada. For complex or urgent matters, 74% said they prefer phone support. It is vendor research on customer service in general.
Willis Automotive Group’s case study shows both halves of the rule at one dealership group in Des Moines, Iowa. Ryan Carlstedt, the group’s EVP of Fixed Operations, describes the text half from the receiving end. “Some people still want you to pick up the phone, and that’s fine. But I’m busy, I’m in meetings. I can get a text message and respond when I get to it.”
The case study’s narration gives the other half. “Advisors still pick up the phone for big jobs, since tone and empathy don’t come through in a text message, but they make those calls prepared.” Before calling, it says, advisors turn the technician’s notes into talking points a customer can follow. It is one group’s practice, offered as an example.
The hard call is where an advisor shines. A customer facing a large repair gets a person who can explain it and answer questions.
Numa perspective: In Numa’s Smart Inbox, an advisor can start a call from the same conversation as the texts. Numa rings the advisor first and then connects the customer, who sees a dealership line while the advisor’s personal cell number stays private. The call is filed in that conversation, so the next teammate sees the texts and the call together.
Where a Phone Call Is the Weaker Choice
A phone call has limits. The first is the customer’s preference.
J.D. Power’s 2026 U.S. Aftermarket Service Index (ASI) Study covers aftermarket service customers at independent and chain shops. Among those who prefer texts and received them, satisfaction was 854. It was 840 when they received a phone call instead.
The release leaves out what those calls were about, and applying an aftermarket finding to a dealership is an inference. It suggests a customer who asked for texts should get a text first, one that can offer the call.
The second limit is the record. A call on its own leaves the customer with nothing to look back at.
The third is the theory. In Dennis and Kinney’s 1998 experiment in Information Systems Research, matching a richer medium to a more ambiguous task did not improve performance. Media richness is a useful way to think about channel choice, with mixed experimental support.
The research for this post also found no dealership study tying a phone call for a repair finding to approval or satisfaction. “Call for the complicated” rests on the channel research, on practice and on one dealership group’s example.
A Working Rule for Text or Call
Five moves turn the rule into a habit. Each one is practice a service manager can teach.
Text the routine. Status updates, pickup notices, confirmations and a single clear approval go by text.
Call for the complicated. Several findings at once, a large estimate, a safety item, a delay or bad news get a short phone call. Numa turns the technician’s notes into a summary the advisor can talk from and drafts the inspection-results text. Nothing sends until the advisor sends it.
Call when a thread keeps going back and forth. A short conversation can settle a question the thread keeps reopening.
Text first, then call. A short text says who is calling and that the call is coming. In a 2020 Pew Research Center survey of 10,211 U.S. adults, eight in ten said they don’t generally answer their cellphone when an unknown number calls. No source here measured whether a text ahead of the call changes how often customers pick up, so this move is practice.
After the call, put it in writing. Text the summary, with any photos and videos: what the customer decided and what it will cost. In J.D. Power’s 2024 CSI Study, satisfaction with the advisor was 911 when photos or videos supported the inspection results and 880 when none were shared. That is a correlation in survey data.
The summary also puts the answer on the record, which an earlier post made the standard for ending a service conversation. If the customer declines the work, it is where the follow-up on declined service work starts.
The Bottom Line: Match the Channel to the Conversation
A text carries the routine update, the photos and the estimate. A voice carries the explanation of a complicated finding and gives the customer room to ask questions. In Numa, a call the advisor starts from the conversation is filed with the texts, so both stay in one place. The rule fits in one line: text for the routine, call for the complicated.
Frequently Asked Questions
When should a service advisor call a customer instead of texting?
Call when the conversation is complicated: several findings at once, a large estimate, a safety item, a delay or bad news. Call too when a text thread keeps going back and forth. Routine updates stay on text. The rule is practice, and applying channel research to a service lane is an inference.
Do service customers prefer a text or a phone call?
For service updates, more customers say text. In J.D. Power’s 2024 U.S. Customer Service Index (CSI) Study, customers were four times as likely to say text message (68%) as phone call (16%). In a 2025 Zogby Analytics survey for Five9, a contact-center software company, 74% of respondents said they prefer phone support for complex or urgent matters.
Should a repair estimate be sent by text?
Yes. The estimate and the photos belong in writing, so the customer can look back at them. In J.D. Power’s 2024 CSI Study, satisfaction with the advisor was 911 when photos or videos supported inspection results and 880 when none were shared. A large or complicated estimate also gets a short call.
How do you get a customer to answer a call from the dealership?
Text first, then call. A short text saying who is calling tells the customer what to expect. In a 2020 Pew Research Center survey, eight in ten Americans said they don’t generally answer their cellphone when an unknown number calls. No study cited here measured whether the text changes how often customers answer.
What number does a customer see when an advisor calls through Numa?
When an advisor starts a call from a conversation in Numa, the customer sees a dealership line. That number belongs to the Numa phone line chosen for the call. The advisor’s personal cell number stays private.
See how Numa keeps an advisor’s calls and texts with a customer in one conversation.


